Meaning of William, It Was Really Nothing (Peel session, August 1984) by The Smiths

Article: Exploring the Enigmatic Themes of The Smiths' "William, It Was Really Nothing"The Smiths, the iconic British indie rock band of the 1980s, have a knack for crafting songs that delve deep into the complexities of human existence and emotion. One such song is "William, It Was Really Nothing," a track that masterfully encapsulates the band's ability to evoke a range of feelings with both its music and lyrics. Upon closer inspection, the song reveals a tapestry of unexpected and imaginative themes that contribute to its overarching message.At its core, "William, It Was Really Nothing" explores the notion of feeling trapped and disillusioned in a humdrum town. The rain falling hard on this town becomes symbolic of the suffocating monotony and gloominess that engulf the lives of its inhabitants. The opening verse masterfully sets the tone for the song, setting the stage for the themes that will unfold.One standout lyric that deserves further examination is "And everybody's got to live their life, and God knows I've got to live mine." This lyric speaks to the universal struggle of individuality and authenticity. It highlights the necessity of forging one's own path, even when surrounded by societal pressures and expectations. In this sense, the song subtly emphasizes the importance of personal autonomy and the pursuit of one's dreams.Another lyric that stands out is "How can you stay with a fat girl who'll say, 'Would you like to marry me?'" While this seemingly straightforward line may initially appear to be about relationships or body image, it takes on a deeper meaning when analyzed within the song's context. It serves as a metaphor for settling and conformity, questioning why one would choose to remain in a stagnant and unfulfilling situation. This theme encourages listeners to challenge societal norms and expectations and to always strive for personal growth and happiness.The chorus of the song, "William, William, it was really nothing," repeated twice, introduces an interesting interpretation. It suggests that the "nothing" William experienced might actually be something significant. This subtle suggestion prompts listeners to reevaluate their own experiences and challenges the notion that certain aspects of life are insignificant or unworthy of attention. Ultimately, the chorus encourages self-reflection and recognition of the value in even the most seemingly trivial experiences.Delving deeper into the theme of self-reflection, the line "I don't dream about anyone, except myself" adds a layer of introspection. It exposes the innate human tendency to be consumed by self-interest and reminds us that our dreams and aspirations are ultimately our own responsibility. This recognition of self-importance ties into the broader message of the song, urging individuals to prioritize their own happiness and seek fulfillment in their own lives.The genius of The Smiths lies in their ability to connect with listeners on a deeply emotional level, prompting introspection and exploration of often overlooked themes. In "William, It Was Really Nothing," they delve into the universal themes of individuality, self-reflection, and the pursuit of personal happiness. Through unexpected and imaginative lyrics, the song encourages listeners to challenge societal norms, embrace their own dreams, and find meaning even in the seemingly insignificant moments of life.As the rain continues to fall on the humdrum town, The Smiths remind us that it is up to us to define our own existence and seek fulfillment. "William, It Was Really Nothing" serves as a poignant reminder to unfurl the confines that hold us back, inspiring us to navigate our own paths and make our lives truly something meaningful.