Meaning of This Charming Man (John Peel Session 14/09/83) by The Smiths

The Smiths' iconic song "This Charming Man" (John Peel Session 14/09/83) is a timeless masterpiece that explores various themes through its thought-provoking lyrics. At first glance, the song appears to revolve around the protagonist's desire to escape mundane existence and join someone in their charming car. However, a closer inspection reveals deeper meanings and unexpected themes that enhance the overall message of the song.One standout lyric in "This Charming Man" is: "Punctured bicycle on a hillside desolate, will nature make a man of me yet?" This line raises the theme of transformation and personal growth. The mentioning of a punctured bicycle suggests that the protagonist is experiencing a setback or obstacle in his life. Yet, the phrase "will nature make a man of me yet?" alludes to the potential for change and improvement. It highlights the idea that while life may present challenges, embracing nature and its unpredictable forces can lead to personal development.In the following verse, the lyrics "Why pamper life's complexities when the leather runs smooth on the passenger seat?" provide an interesting contrast. Here, the theme of superficiality is introduced. The leather in the passenger seat represents material comfort and luxury, while the complexities of life symbolize deeper emotional and intellectual pursuits. This lyric critiques the idea of indulging in superficiality instead of embracing the complexities that make life meaningful. It implies that choosing material pleasure over personal growth may lead to an empty existence.The chorus of the song contains the lyrics: "A jumped-up pantry boy who never knew his place, he said, 'Return the rings,' he knows so much about these things." This verse introduces themes of identity and social hierarchy. The phrase "jumped-up pantry boy" refers to someone who displays a disregard for their social status or acts above their station. This portrays a character who is unapologetically defying societal expectations and norms. The line "Return the rings" can be interpreted as a demand to reject material symbols of commitment. It challenges the idea that material possessions define relationships and suggests the importance of genuine connection.Continuing on the theme of identity, the lyrics "I would go out tonight but I haven't got a stitch to wear, this man said, 'It's gruesome that someone so handsome should care'" add a layer of vulnerability. The protagonist's lack of suitable clothing highlights a feeling of inadequacy, being unprepared to face the world. This lyric suggests that appearances can be deceiving, emphasizing the inner struggles that lie beneath the surface of an outwardly charming individual. The contrast between the protagonist's attractiveness and their internal doubts reveals the complexities and insecurities of human nature.To further delve into unexpected themes, the song's bridge features the repetition of "Na, na na, na na, na na, this charming man" and "La, da da, da da, da da, this charming man." These playful, almost nonsensical phrases can be seen as a commentary on the elusiveness of charm. Charm, often associated with attractiveness, can be used as a shield to hide one's true self. This suggests that sometimes, what appears charming on the surface masks deeper, more complex emotions and motivations.Overall, "This Charming Man" by The Smiths is no ordinary song. Its lyrics provoke imaginative and unexpected themes that enrich the listener's understanding of the human condition. From personal growth and transformation to societal hierarchies and the complexities of human nature, the song encapsulates a range of themes that resonate deeply with its audience. Through its thought-provoking lyrics, "This Charming Man" invites us to question the nature of charm, the pursuit of material possessions, and the true essence of our identities. It continues to captivate and inspire listeners, solidifying its place as a timeless classic in the world of music.