The Fall of the House of Usher: Why does Frederick want to bring Morelle home against medical orders?

In episode 5 of The Fall of the House of Usher, titled "The Tell-Tale Heart," Frederick Usher, one of the remaining Usher siblings, goes against medical orders and makes arrangements to bring his wife, Morelle, home. The reason behind his decision is not solely based on concern for her well-being. Frederick harbors a deep-seated paranoia and a desire for justice due to his belief that Morelle betrayed his trust.Throughout the series, Verna, the antagonist, has been manipulating and isolating the Usher children, fueling their paranoia and driving them to madness. While most of the siblings have fallen under Verna's influence, Frederick remains somewhat resistant to her control. However, he also carries his own personal demons, which contribute to his decision to bring Morelle home against medical advice.Frederick sees this as an opportunity to have Morelle within his grasp and confront her for betraying his trust. He believes that by forcing her to come back home, he can exact his own version of justice and determine the truth behind her alleged betrayal. This decision is driven by his need for closure and a distorted sense of justice, fueled by his paranoia and the toxic environment created by Verna.The dynamics among the Usher siblings are complex, as they navigate their own personal issues while dealing with the manipulative tactics of Verna. Frederick, along with Tamerlane and Victorine, attempts to unite against their common enemy, but their personal grievances and suspicions hinder their ability to fully come together.As the Usher children grapple with their own challenges, the series also explores the investigation conducted by Arthur Pym and the confession made by Auguste Dupin. Dupin reveals that he fabricated the existence of an informant in order to manipulate the Usher siblings and turn them against each other. However, he did not anticipate the extent to which this would lead to tragedy and death.The episode culminates in a shocking revelation surrounding Victorine's fate. Victorine, consumed by guilt and abandoned by her girlfriend, Alessandra, starts hearing a mysterious mechanical chirping sound that haunts her. As the sound follows her everywhere, she becomes increasingly disturbed. In a dramatic twist, it is revealed that Victorine accidentally killed Alessandra during an altercation, and in a desperate attempt to revive her, opened her chest and implanted the experimental heart mesh. The mechanical chirping that Victorine hears is actually the sound of the machine attempting to pump blood through a dead heart.This horrifying revelation is portrayed masterfully by Mike Flanagan, the creator of the series. The moment when Roderick, Victorine's father, discovers Alessandra's lifeless body with her chest open is particularly gut-wrenching. Victorine's subsequent realization of her ghastly acts leads her to stab herself in the heart in front of her shocked father, mirroring the scene where Roderick contemplates self-harm.In conclusion, Frederick's decision to bring Morelle home against medical orders is driven by a mix of paranoia, a desire for justice, and his own personal demons. The episode delves deeper into the manipulations of Verna and the psychological unraveling of the Usher siblings. The shocking revelation surrounding Victorine's actions adds a new level of horror to the series, as the characters continue to confront their own darkness and navigate the complexities of their twisted family history.

Previous
Previous

The Fall of the House of Usher: Why do Frederick and Tamerlane hate Victorine?

Next
Next

The Fall of the House of Usher: Who is in the pictures that Arthur Pym finds?