Meaning of But Not Them by Siouxsie and the Banshees

The Siouxsie and the Banshees song titled 'But Not Them' is an intriguing composition that delves into various themes and emotions. Taking a closer look at the lyrics, we can explore the haunting messages hidden within the verses. With its cryptic storytelling and imaginative language, the song presents a world where love and hatred coexist, and where individuals struggle against societal constraints.One of the overarching themes in 'But Not Them' is the tension between two opposing sides, represented by the man and the girl. Both pairs passionately hate each other due to denied desires, which creates an atmosphere of hostility and frustration. This theme highlights the complexities of human relationships, as it suggests that even those who seem similar may hold animosity towards one another. The lyrics emphasize the depth of their emotions, hinting at the intensity of these internal conflicts.In the line, "The girl isn't alive - but the man is dead because it's all been said before," we encounter a fascinating contradiction. This lyric points towards the idea of emotional stagnancy and the inability to truly live when constantly dwelling in past experiences. Here, the song suggests that the girl, in a metaphorical sense, lacks the vibrancy and zest for life. Conversely, the man is described as dead, emphasizing the emotional toll that repetition and unfulfilled desires can have on a person. This lyric explores the theme of the burden of the past and the importance of embracing new experiences.Additionally, the line, "The girl isn't alive - but the man is dead because you only have your mentor to draw - you whore," introduces themes of dependency and manipulation. This lyric speaks to the notion of reliance on others for guidance and validation. The term "mentor" implies a power dynamic, with the girl being controlled or influenced by someone else. The use of the derogatory term "whore" deepens the complexity of the relationship, suggesting a transactional aspect and exploring themes of betrayal and exploitation. This theme of dependency raises questions about identity and agency, challenging societal norms and power structures.Furthermore, the repeated phrase, "Dead lumps of meat melt in this heat," contributes to the overall theme of decay and destruction. This poetic imagery conjures a sense of decay, suggesting that both the man and the girl are slowly deteriorating under the pressures of their internal conflicts. The heat mentioned in the lyrics intensifies the feeling of suffocating within the confines of their emotions. This theme portrays the consequences of unresolved issues and the destructive nature of internal struggle.Overall, the song 'But Not Them' delves into the complexities of human relationships, unfulfilled desires, emotional stagnancy, dependency, and decay. The standout lyrics seamlessly weave these imaginative themes into a haunting narrative, drawing listeners into a world of intense emotions and conflicting desires. Siouxsie and the Banshees masterfully explore the darker aspects of the human psyche, challenging societal conventions and inviting introspection. Through their unique storytelling and provocative language, the band crafts a musical experience that prompts listeners to reflect on their own internal conflicts and the consequences of denying their true desires.