Max Beerbohm: 'As a teacher, as a propagandist, Mr. Shaw is no good at all, even in his own generation. But as a personality, he is immortal.'

As a teacher, as a propagandist, Mr. Shaw is no good at all, even in his own generation. But as a personality, he is immortal.

In his insightful statement, Max Beerbohm captures the essence of George Bernard Shaw's impact on the literary world. "As a teacher, as a propagandist, Mr. Shaw is no good at all, even in his own generation. But as a personality, he is immortal." At first glance, this quote seems to indicate that Shaw's influence as an educator or advocate for specific ideologies was limited. However, upon deeper reflection, it unveils a much more profound meaning—one that delves into the concept of immortal personalities and their lasting legacy.Beerbohm's observations can be understood as a comparative analysis between Shaw's effectiveness as a teacher or agent of persuasion versus his impact as an enduring figure in the annals of history. Shaw's qualities may not have translated well as a pedagogue or a propagandist, as they did not resonate strongly with his contemporaries. Nevertheless, it is his persona, his personality, that has granted him everlasting recognition.This notion of an immortal personality brings forth an intriguing philosophical concept: the distinction between transitory influence and lasting legacy. While one may possess exceptional teaching skills or persuasive abilities, their impact may fade over time. On the other hand, individuals endowed with charismatic personalities, regardless of their effectiveness as educators or advocates, leave an indelible mark on history.To better understand this distinction, let us consider some examples from various domains. Take the realm of teaching itself; it is not uncommon to encounter educators who possess remarkable knowledge and expertise but fail to connect with their students. Despite their mastery of the subject matter, their influence may wane as students move on and their lessons fade from memory. Conversely, teachers who possess a captivating personality, an infectious passion for their subject, and a deep empathy with their students are more likely to leave a lasting impact.Similarly, in the field of politics, there are leaders who excel in promoting their ideologies and rallying support, only to be forgotten once their time in power ends. Their persuasive abilities may have garnered them followers during their tenure, but their legacy proves ephemeral. However, leaders who possess an immortal personality—those who inspire, embody values, and lead by example—continue to resonate with generations to come.Returning to Shaw, we can see that his essence as a personality transcends the limits of time and context. His wit, intelligence, and formidable presence made him an unforgettable figure, irrespective of the specific causes he championed or the lessons he imparted. Shaw's unique blend of eccentricity, humor, and intellect engrained him in the public consciousness. His plays, like "Pygmalion" and "Man and Superman," continue to be performed worldwide, perpetuating his legacy.It is crucial to remember that an immortal personality does not imply perfection or universal adoration. Indeed, some personalities endure due to their controversial nature or the debates they engender. Consider figures like Nietzsche or Freud, whose ideas and personas continue to spark fascination and fervent discussions decades after their passing. Their enduring impact stems from their ability to challenge conventions and provoke new ways of thinking, rather than their effectiveness as teachers or propagandists.In summary, Max Beerbohm's quote about George Bernard Shaw encapsulates the distinction between his effectiveness as a teacher or advocate and his immortal personality. It prompts us to reflect on the lasting impact of charisma, character, and individuality compared to one's immediate influence. While teaching and persuasion are important, it is the power of personal connection and a lasting impression that truly immortals an individual. These immortal personalities are the ones whose legacies endure, spurring conversations and captivating future generations, even if their specific messages might be overshadowed by time.