A. N. Wilson: 'The really clever people now want to be lawyers or journalists.'

The really clever people now want to be lawyers or journalists.

In A. N. Wilson's thought-provoking statement, "The really clever people now want to be lawyers or journalists," he addresses a shift in societal perception towards the perceived "cleverness" of individuals pursuing careers in law or journalism. This quote carries a certain meaning and importance in shedding light on the evolving dynamics of intellectual pursuits in modern times. However, to truly explore the depths of this topic and captivate the readers' attention, it is fascinating to introduce an unexpected philosophical concept that will infuse a sense of intrigue and curiosity into the article.While the quote initially captures our attention with its simple interpretation, suggesting that intelligence and ambition are redirected towards the fields of law and journalism, delving deeper reveals a broader theme concerning the definition of intellectual prowess. It prompts us to question why law and journalism have come to be regarded as domains for "clever" individuals. What does it mean for one to be "clever"? And are those who pursue other paths somehow deemed less intelligent?At this juncture, an unexpected philosophical concept from Plato's "Allegory of the Cave" can be introduced to explore and contrast with Wilson's quote. Plato describes a captivating story where people are chained in a cave, observing only shadows projected on the wall, perceiving those shadows as reality. When one prisoner escapes and ventures into the outside world, their perception of reality expands exponentially. Plato uses this allegory to illustrate that true intelligence lies not in accepting the shadows we see or the popular notions of cleverness but in challenging those perceptions, seeking knowledge, and questioning the status quo.Drawing from Plato's allegory, we can compare how the notion of "cleverness" in Wilson's quote aligns with the prisoners in the cave, content with their limited knowledge and accepting the popular narrative. Those pursuing careers in law and journalism, while undoubtedly valuable in society, are constrained within certain boundaries. Lawyers navigate complex legal frameworks, and journalists often adhere to subjective editorial policies and societal expectations. Their cleverness lies in the mastery of these domains rather than challenging the inherent limitations of their chosen paths.Contrasting this, the truly intellectual individuals, as per Plato's philosophy, transcend the constraints imposed by societal norms and popular careers. They venture outside the cave to explore uncharted territories, challenge established thought patterns, and seek comprehension beyond the superficial shadows. These individuals might be found pursuing careers in fields like philosophy, science, or the arts, where innovation and intellectual curiosity thrive.While society may idolize the lawyers and journalists for their seemingly clever pursuits, it is essential not to dismiss the intellectual depths achieved by those who choose divergent paths. It is their ability to question, to think independently, and to challenge established norms that drives progress and pushes the boundaries of human knowledge and understanding. These "alternative intellectuals" possess the innate hunger for wisdom and the audacity to traverse unexplored territories, emulating the liberated prisoner in Plato's allegory.In conclusion, A. N. Wilson's quote sparks contemplation on the shifting perception of intelligence in the modern world, where law and journalism have come to be associated with cleverness. By integrating the unexpected philosophical concept of Plato's "Allegory of the Cave," we are reminded that true intellectual prowess extends beyond conforming to societal expectations. The quote prompts us to reflect on the distinction between accepting the shadows presented to us and actively pursuing wisdom by challenging the status quo. In doing so, we acknowledge and appreciate the intellectual diversity found among individuals who venture beyond the confines of popular careers, continually seeking knowledge and questioning the boundaries of human thought.