A. N. Wilson: 'Iris Murdoch did influence my early novels very much, and influence is never entirely good.'

Iris Murdoch did influence my early novels very much, and influence is never entirely good.

In the realm of literature, authors often draw inspiration from the works of others, allowing the influence to shape their own creative endeavors. British writer A. N. Wilson once commented on the impact of Iris Murdoch on his early novels, stating that influence is never entirely good. This quote holds great meaning and importance as it highlights the complex nature of influence and its potential effects on an individual's artistic output. While influence can ignite creativity and provide a foundation for growth, it can also lead to imitation and hinder the development of a distinct personal style. However, delving deeper into this topic reveals a fascinating philosophical concept that adds a layer of interest to the discussion: the dichotomy of originality versus authenticity.To begin with, let's unpack the straightforward meaning of Wilson's quote. By acknowledging the influence of Iris Murdoch on his early novels, Wilson recognizes the imprint that another writer can leave on a budding author's creative journey. Influence, in this context, refers to the impact and inspiration gained from observing the works, ideas, or techniques of another individual. And while it is undoubtedly beneficial to learn from those who have come before, Wilson suggests that influence is not without its drawbacks. This acknowledgement is significant as it raises the question of how much influence is beneficial versus when it becomes stifling or inhibiting to an artist's individuality.Introducing the concept of the originality-authenticity dichotomy adds a layer of intrigue to the discussion. On one hand, originality pertains to the creation of something distinctly new and unique, devoid of any external influence or imitation. It showcases the artist's ability to forge their path and bring fresh ideas to the forefront. On the other hand, authenticity relates to the genuine expression of an artist's true self, unburdened by the pressure to conform to trends or to imitate the works of others. It is a reflection of the artist's voice, beliefs, and personal experiences.When considering the influence of Iris Murdoch on Wilson's early novels through the lens of originality, it becomes evident that this influence may have hindered his ability to create something entirely his own. While Wilson's early works may have shown glimpses of potential, the shadow of Murdoch's influence could have constrained his ability to fully explore his own ideas and artistic style. In this sense, the influence may not have been entirely good, as Wilson suggests.However, when examined from the perspective of authenticity, the influence takes on a different light. Authenticity encourages artists to embrace their influences and use them as a springboard for the development of their unique voice. In this light, the influence of Iris Murdoch on Wilson's early novels becomes an integral part of his journey towards becoming a distinct writer. It serves as the foundation from which he can build upon, allowing his own experiences and voice to shape his work and ultimately contribute to his authenticity as an author. In this sense, influence becomes a catalyst for growth, and while not entirely good, it becomes a necessary stepping stone on the path to authenticity.In conclusion, A. N. Wilson's quote regarding Iris Murdoch's influence on his early novels captures the multifaceted nature of influence in the realm of literature. While influence can be a valuable source of inspiration and growth, it can also limit an artist's ability to fully express their originality. By introducing the philosophical concept of the originality-authenticity dichotomy, we gain a deeper understanding of the complexities at play. Ultimately, it is up to the artist to navigate the fine line between embracing influence for growth and ensuring their work remains authentic expressions of their own unique voice.