Todd Gitlin: 'Some versions of patriotism come close to the tribal, which we all want to surpass, and some don't.'

Some versions of patriotism come close to the tribal, which we all want to surpass, and some don't.

In his thought-provoking quote, Todd Gitlin introduces the idea that patriotism can sometimes resemble tribalism, a mindset that many of us aspire to transcend. He highlights how patriotism can manifest in different forms, some of which may perpetuate narrow-mindedness and exclusivity, while others exhibit a more inclusive and enlightened perspective. This quote urges us to examine the various expressions of patriotism and question whether they align with our aspirations as a society.At first glance, the quote may appear straightforward, emphasizing the importance of moving beyond tribalistic patriotism. However, let's delve into a philosophical concept that could add depth and intrigue to the discussion: existentialism. Existentialism emphasizes individual existence, freedom, and the idea that each person is responsible for creating their own meaning in life. By exploring the relationship between patriotism and existentialism, we can gain a fresh perspective on Gitlin's quote.Existentialism challenges us to reflect on the motives behind patriotic fervor. Are we embracing patriotism out of blind conformity, following the tribal instincts to seek safety, belonging, and identity? Or are we driven by a genuine love for our country, coupled with a responsible and critical engagement with its values, principles, and faults?When patriotism takes on a tribalistic nature, it manifests as a rigid and exclusionary force. It leads individuals to view their country as superior to others and fosters an "us versus them" mentality. In such cases, patriotism becomes a tool of division and hostility, rather than a unifying and inclusive force that can bring people together. This narrow-minded version of patriotism fails to recognize the diversity and interconnectedness of our globalized world, hampering our progress as a species.Yet, not all forms of patriotism fall into this trap. Some expressions of love for one's country go beyond tribal boundaries and embrace a broader perspective. These forms of patriotism acknowledge the flaws and complexities of their nation while striving for progress, inclusivity, and social justice. They recognize that true patriotism entails holding their country to high moral standards and being actively engaged in shaping its future. This enlightened patriotism seeks to unite people across borders, aiming to bridge the gaps between cultures, respecting diversity, and fostering international cooperation.By juxtaposing tribalistic patriotism with the existentialist ideals of individualism and personal responsibility, Gitlin's quote invites us to critically examine our allegiance to our respective nations. It prompts us to ponder whether our patriotic inclinations stem from genuine introspection and personal conviction, grounded in a broader understanding of our interconnectedness with others.In essence, Gitlin's quote serves as a call to transcend the limitations of tribalistic patriotism. It encourages us to embrace a version of patriotism that does not rest solely on blind loyalty, but rather stems from a thoughtful evaluation of our nation's progress and flaws. By fostering an inclusive and enlightened patriotism, we can actively contribute to a more peaceful, just, and interconnected world. So let us question and broaden our perspectives, and strive for a patriotism that surpasses the tribal.