Robertson Davies: 'Their very conservatism is secondhand, and they don't know what they are conserving.'

Their very conservatism is secondhand, and they don't know what they are conserving.

In the literary world, few quotes have the power to ignite introspection and contemplation like Robertson Davies' profound statement: "Their very conservatism is secondhand, and they don't know what they are conserving." At first glance, this quote appears to highlight the hollowness of blind adherence to tradition, suggesting that individuals who uphold conservative values often do so without a full understanding of the underlying principles they are safeguarding. However, when viewed through an unexpected philosophical lens, the quote offers a fascinating perspective on the nature of identity, authenticity, and the inherent tension between tradition and progress.At its core, the aforementioned quote serves as a cautionary reminder against the mindless perpetuation of conservative ideas merely for the sake of preservation. Davies implies that many individuals who cling to conservative beliefs uncritically inherit them from the past, without a sincere comprehension of their true essence or relevance to the present. This interpretation highlights the dangers of intellectual laziness and the perpetuation of dogmas that may no longer serve a meaningful purpose.To delve deeper into the significance of this quote, let's introduce the philosophical concept of existential authenticity. Drawing inspiration from existential philosophers like Jean-Paul Sartre and Martin Heidegger, we can explore how the notion of "authentic existence" relates to the quote and offers a fresh perspective on conservatism.Existential authenticity emphasizes the importance of self-reflection and personal responsibility in shaping one's life. It calls upon individuals to question societal expectations, inherited beliefs, and preconceived notions in order to align their actions and values with their true selves. When applied to the quote by Davies, existential authenticity invites us to consider whether true conservatism arises from personal understanding and conviction, or if it is merely a secondhand adoption.By contrasting conservatism grounded in authentic existence with the kind described in the quote, we can discern profound differences. Authentic conservatism emerges from reflective introspection, where individuals have critically evaluated the principles they embrace and consciously chosen to adhere to them. In contrast, secondhand conservatism lacks the introspective depth necessary to comprehend the beliefs being upheld.Furthermore, existential authenticity encourages individuals to redefine their beliefs and challenge the status quo when necessary, even within a conservative framework. This philosophy recognizes that progress, growth, and adaptation should be embraced alongside tradition, creating a dynamic equilibrium. In light of this, it becomes crucial for conservatives to interrogate their principles continually, understand their essence, and assess their compatibility with the evolving world.Encouragingly, Davies' quote does not condemn conservatism altogether but rather serves as a call to action for conservatives to engage in self-reflection and critical thinking. Rather than blindly safeguarding tradition, individuals are implored to embark on a journey of self-discovery and intellectual exploration to develop a conscious conservatism that withstands the test of time. This approach not only ensures the preservation of valuable ideological foundations but also allows for the necessary evolution and adaptation to remain relevant in a rapidly changing world.In conclusion, Robertson Davies' quote holds immense significance and provokes deep contemplation about the nature of conservatism. When examined through the lens of existential authenticity, we begin to appreciate the wisdom hidden within the quote's simplicity. It highlights the importance of self-reflection, critical thinking, and the continuous reevaluation of our beliefs. By embracing such principles, conservatives can elevate their ideologies beyond secondhand conservatism and navigate a path that integrates tradition and progress harmoniously. It is through this introspective journey that one can truly understand and appreciate the essence of conservatism they choose to conserve while embodying authenticity in their beliefs and actions.