Robert Hall: 'In matters of conscience, first thoughts are best. In matters of prudence, last thoughts are best.'

In matters of conscience, first thoughts are best. In matters of prudence, last thoughts are best.

In his quote, Robert Hall explores the intricacies of decision-making, distinguishing between matters of conscience and matters of prudence. He suggests that when it comes to matters of conscience, our initial thoughts hold greater weight and value. On the other hand, in matters of prudence, our final thoughts, after careful consideration and assessment, are deemed to be more sound and effective. This quote highlights the importance of introspection and deliberation in decision-making processes while acknowledging the subtle distinctions between matters of conscience and prudence.At first glance, the quote appears to provide a simple guideline for decision-making. When faced with matters of conscience, those internal moral dilemmas we all encounter, our initial thoughts hold a certain purity and authenticity. They are the immediate responses that emerge from our deepest values and beliefs, untainted by outside influence. In these instances, it is essential to trust our initial instincts, as they align with our core principles and innermost convictions. To act in harmony with our conscience is to act in accordance with our true selves.However, matters of prudence differ from matters of conscience. Prudence refers to those decisions involving practical judgment, where careful consideration of the possible consequences is necessary. Unlike matters of conscience, which deal with moral integrity and personal values, matters of prudence demand a more analytical approach. Here, it is crucial to engage in a thorough thought process, taking into account various factors such as risks, benefits, and potential outcomes. In these situations, our final thoughts, shaped by reflection and prudence, tend to yield the most prudent and practical decisions.While Hall's quote addresses an important aspect of decision-making, an unexpected philosophical concept, namely the presence of an existential self, sheds further light on his viewpoint. When it comes to matters of conscience, our initial thoughts may be considered the voice of our existential self. This existential self is the timeless part of us that connects us to our deepest values, our sense of purpose, and our understanding of right and wrong. It is a deeply ingrained moral compass that guides us in ethical considerations. Therefore, trusting our initial thoughts in matters of conscience means listening to the profound wisdom of our existential self.In contrast, matters of prudence involve assessing the practical ramifications of our decisions. In these instances, our final thoughts are shaped by a different aspect of our self, the conditional self. The conditional self is the part of us that interacts with the external world, considering the complex web of cause and effect. It takes into account the practical aspects, the potential consequences, and the impact our decisions may have on ourselves and others. By relying on our final thoughts in matters of prudence, we ensure that we have weighed all the relevant information and considered every possible outcome before making a decision.Understanding the distinction between matters of conscience, prudence, and the presence of the existential and conditional self brings depth and complexity to Hall's quote. It reminds us that decision-making is multifaceted and requires us to tap into various dimensions of our being. By acknowledging and appreciating these different aspects, we become more attuned to our inner selves and make more informed choices.In conclusion, Robert Hall's quote speaks to the importance of our initial thoughts in matters of conscience and our final thoughts in matters of prudence. It encourages us to trust the inner voice of our existential self when faced with ethical dilemmas, while also emphasizing the need for careful deliberation and analysis in decisions that involve practical judgment. By recognizing the existence of different aspects of our self, we gain a deeper understanding of our decision-making processes and can navigate the complexities of life with greater integrity and wisdom.