J. R. R. Tolkien: 'Go not to the Elves for counsel, for they will say both no and yes.'

Go not to the Elves for counsel, for they will say both no and yes.

J.R.R. Tolkien, the mastermind behind the enchanting world of Middle-Earth, left us with a treasure trove of profound quotes and wisdom. Amongst them, one that stands out is, 'Go not to the Elves for counsel, for they will say both no and yes.' At first glance, this quote appears to caution against seeking advice from the wise and ancient Elves. However, delving deeper, we can unravel a hidden philosophical concept that adds intrigue and depth to Tolkien's words.In a straightforward sense, this quote warns against the potential ambiguity in seeking counsel from the Elves. It suggests that the Elven wisdom is not straightforward and can provide conflicting answers, both affirmative and negative. This duality in their responses might lead one astray, creating confusion rather than clarity. Reflecting the intricate nature of Elves themselves, this quote serves as a reminder to approach their counsel with caution and discernment.But what lies beyond this surface-level interpretation? Digging into Tolkien's rich lore, we encounter the concept of relative ethics, which can shed light on the deeper meaning behind the quote. Within Middle-Earth, Elves are known for their unparalleled knowledge, unwavering moral compass, and long-sighted perspective. Their decision-making is not swayed by emotion or haste but is anchored in timeless wisdom.This philosophical concept emphasizes the relativity of ethical decision-making, as opposed to fixed rules or absolute judgments. The Elves, characterized by their profound insight into the interconnectedness of all things, understand the complexity of existence and the shades of gray that often cloak our choices. In their counsel, they acknowledge the multifaceted nature of reality and provide responses that encompass different perspectives, reflecting the intricate tapestry of existence.In the world outside of Elven realms, where mortals strive to navigate the moral labyrinth of right and wrong, this can be disorienting. We are conditioned to seek clear-cut answers, to categorize choices into the boxes of black and white. The Elves, armed with their profound understanding of life's nuances, challenge us to embrace the ambiguity inherent in ethical decision-making.This concept of relative ethics can be observed in practical terms when examining the inhabitants of Middle-Earth. Take for example the rivalry between the Dwarves and the Elves. Both races have valid perspectives and motivations, but their contrasting values often lead to clashes. When seeking counsel from the Elves, it is crucial to recognize that their responses might be colored by their inherent biases, shaped by their unique understanding of the world. Thus, understanding the source of their wisdom and recognizing its limitations grants us the wisdom to navigate our own path.Moreover, relativity in ethics found within this quote can be extended beyond the Elves. In our everyday lives, we encounter a myriad of perspectives, each offering unique advice and insight. Just as the Elves provide divergent responses, so too do the multitude of voices we encounter throughout our journey. Recognizing the relativity of ethics allows us to engage in a holistic decision-making process, taking into account diverse perspectives that suit the multifaceted nature of our world.Tolkien's quote, 'Go not to the Elves for counsel, for they will say both no and yes,' serves as a beautiful reminder of the intricate moral fabric that surrounds us, urging us to embrace the complexities of decision-making. While cautioning against relying solely on the guidance of a single source, it also invites us to broaden our understanding of ethics, acknowledging the relativity inherent in our choices. By approaching counsel with discernment, acknowledging the biases of those who offer it, and embracing the nuances of ethical decision-making, we can navigate the labyrinth of life with a deeper understanding and wisdom.