Edward Hall: 'Shakespeare reveals human nature brilliantly: he shines a light on our instinctive desire to dominate each other.'

Shakespeare reveals human nature brilliantly: he shines a light on our instinctive desire to dominate each other.

In his profound statement, Edward Hall encapsulates the timeless brilliance of Shakespeare's works by asserting that the playwright skillfully exposes the innate inclination within human nature to exert dominance over others. This quote highlights an essential aspect of Shakespeare's plays, where characters constantly strive to gain power and control in their interactions with one another. It invites us to contemplate the complex dynamics of human relationships, exploring the motivations behind our desire to dominate and the consequences it may entail.The significance of this quote lies in its representation of a universal truth that resonates throughout history and across cultures. Shakespeare's timeless themes continue to captivate audiences and readers alike precisely because they tap into fundamental aspects of the human condition. Whether it is the power struggle between Macbeth and Lady Macbeth, the political maneuverings in Julius Caesar, or the familial conflicts in King Lear, Shakespeare masterfully portrays the multifaceted nature of dominance.However, to further explore this topic, it is fascinating to introduce a philosophical concept that challenges the notion of domination as an instinctive desire. By delving into the philosophies of Michel Foucault, an influential thinker of the 20th century, we can present an unexpected perspective on power dynamics. Foucault argues that power is not something possessed by individuals or groups but rather a fluid force that permeates every aspect of society. He suggests that power operates not only through dominance, but also through more subtle mechanisms like discipline, surveillance, and control.Drawing a juxtaposition between Shakespeare's portrayal of dominance and Foucault's concept of power opens up a rich and nuanced exploration of human nature. While Shakespeare undoubtedly depicts characters who actively seek to dominate others, Foucault's framework encourages us to question the ways in which power manifests itself beyond simple domination. It prompts us to consider the underlying structures and systems that influence and shape individuals and societies.Applying this theoretical lens, we can uncover that Shakespeare's works do not solely shine a light on our instinctive desire to dominate but also reveal the intricate complexities of power relations. Through his characters, Shakespeare unveils the multifaceted nature of power, showing how it encompasses not only overt acts of dominance but also the subtle ways in which authority is asserted and maintained.Furthermore, within Shakespeare's plays, we can find examples that challenge the notion of dominance as a natural instinct. Characters such as Portia in "The Merchant of Venice" demonstrate qualities of empathy, compassion, and a desire for justice that question the overpowering desire to dominate others. Their actions highlight the potential for alternative forms of power, ones grounded in fairness, understanding, and mutual respect.In conclusion, Edward Hall's quote about Shakespeare's illumination of human nature's instinctive desire for dominance captivates our attention by delving into the intricate web of power dynamics. However, by introducing the philosophies of Foucault and exploring alternative forms of power within Shakespeare's plays, we can enrich our understanding of this complex topic. Ultimately, Shakespeare's works serve as a mirror reflecting the multifaceted nature of power, inviting us to critically reflect on the dynamics that shape our relationships and society as a whole.