Harvey Weinstein: 'When people ask me what makes movies great, it's the material.'

When people ask me what makes movies great, it's the material.

The quote, "When people ask me what makes movies great, it's the material," by Harvey Weinstein, encapsulates the essence of what truly sets outstanding films apart. In a straightforward manner, the quote suggests that the foundation of any exceptional movie lies in its screenplay or story. Weinstein, a renowned film producer, understands that regardless of the director's vision or the talent of the actors, without compelling material, a movie may fall flat.The importance of the quote lies in its acknowledgment of the power of storytelling in the world of cinema. It emphasizes that the substance of a film, its plot, characters, and underlying themes, is the driving force behind its success. This concept highlights the significance of investing in well-written scripts and compelling narratives, rather than solely relying on the allure of impressive visuals or star-studded casts.While Weinstein's quote provides a direct insight into what makes movies great, it also opens up space for a more profound philosophical discussion. The concept of materiality in films represents a tangible aspect, something concrete that can be seen or experienced. Yet, there is another dimension of storytelling that goes beyond the material realm - the intangible, the realm of ideas and emotions.Philosophically, the distinction between materiality and immateriality draws parallels to the philosophical concept of the mind and body dualism. In the context of films, this dualism can be understood by comparing the material representation, the physical aspects such as the visuals and performances, with the immaterial aspects such as storytelling techniques and emotional resonance.When discussing movies, it is tempting to focus only on the concrete elements, such as the brilliant cinematography, stunning costumes, or extraordinary set designs. While these material components contribute to the overall cinematic experience, it is the immaterial ingredients that weave together the heart and soul of a film.The immaterial aspects encompass the art of storytelling - the ability to make the audience think, feel, and reflect upon the film's narrative long after leaving the theater. It includes the choices made by the director and screenwriter in structuring the plot, developing characters, and exploring profound themes. This intangible dimension, often referred to as the essence or spirit of a film, constitutes the emotional and intellectual impact it leaves on the viewers.In comparing the material and immaterial elements of movies, one could argue that while the material aspects capture the immediate attention, it is the immaterial that lingers in our minds, shaping our understanding and perception of the film in the long run. This distinction emphasizes that a truly great movie is not solely defined by its visual aesthetics but rather by its ability to touch our hearts and provoke meaningful contemplation.By delving into this concept of materiality and immateriality within the realm of cinema, we enhance our appreciation for the art of storytelling. It urges us to consider the intricate interplay between the visible and invisible, the tangible and intangible, enabling us to develop a more nuanced understanding of the factors that contribute to the greatness of movies.Ultimately, Harvey Weinstein's quote serves as a starting point for exploring the multifaceted nature of filmmaking. It reminds us that while the material, visible elements undoubtedly hold significance, it is the immaterial, the storytelling itself, that fundamentally elevates a film from being merely good to truly exceptional. As viewers, we should strive to appreciate and analyze these immaterial aspects, thereby deepening our appreciation for the power of cinema as an art form.