Charlotte Perkins Gilman: 'New York - that unnatural city where every one is an exile, none more so than the American.'

New York - that unnatural city where every one is an exile, none more so than the American.

In her quote, Charlotte Perkins Gilman captures the essence of New York City as an unnatural place, where the sense of exile is pervasive, particularly for Americans. This quote resonates with New York's reputation as a melting pot or a city where people from all walks of life come together, often leaving behind their roots and identities. The metropolis is known for its diverse population, with people from different cultures, backgrounds, and nationalities trying to find their place in a bustling, fast-paced environment. However, Gilman's assertion that Americans specifically feel like exiles in the city adds an intriguing layer to consider.At first glance, the concept of an American feeling like an exile in their own country might sound paradoxical. After all, New York City is located within the United States, and it can be seen as a representation of American culture and ideals. Yet, Gilman's observation points to the immense diversity within the city that can make even an American feel like a foreigner. The city's international character and the constant exposure to different customs, languages, and traditions can create a sense of dislocation for Americans who may find themselves surrounded by unfamiliar experiences.In exploring this notion further, we can delve into a philosophical concept that adds depth to Gilman's quote: the idea of existentialism. Existentialism, a philosophy rooted in the exploration of human existence and individuality, asserts that each individual is responsible for creating their own meaning and purpose in life. In the context of New York City, this philosophical concept becomes intriguingly relevant.New York's relentless energy, its constant movement and progress, can be seen as a reflection of the existentialist philosophy. Existentialism encourages individuals to confront the discomfort of uncertainty and embrace the freedom to define their own identities. In this light, New York City becomes an existential playground, challenging Americans to question their own sense of belonging and to find meaning within the chaos and unfamiliarity.Contrasting the experience of an American in New York City with that of someone who comes from a different country adds another layer of complexity. While Americans might feel like exiles due to the city's diverse population and the clash of different cultures, individuals from other countries might find solace in the shared experience of being a foreigner. The common ground of being outsiders can foster both a sense of community and an appreciation for the diverse tapestry that makes up New York City. Thus, the city becomes a microcosm of the world, where different people coexist and adapt, shaping their identities within the constant flow of interactions.In conclusion, Charlotte Perkins Gilman's quote shines a light on the paradoxical nature of New York City as an unnatural place where even Americans can feel like exiles. By introducing the philosophical concept of existentialism, we can further explore the significance of this observation. New York City becomes a metaphorical playground that challenges and inspires individuals from all backgrounds to define their own senses of belonging and purpose, ultimately contributing to the vibrant mosaic that characterizes this captivating metropolis.